Mountain biking is a thrilling sport that has attracted many enthusiasts around the world. With the advent of new technology, riders can now customize their bikes to fit their individual taste and needs. One popular upgrade is replacing the cranks on a mountain bike with BMX cranks. This has become a subject of debate, with some cyclists advocating for it while others consider it dangerous.
The main difference between BMX cranks and mountain bike cranks is their length. BMX cranks are shorter, allowing for better control and maneuverability on tight corners. This feature has made them popular among BMX riders, but some mountain bike riders believe that they may not be suitable for their sport. This article will explore the feasibility of using BMX cranks on a mountain bike and what potential advantages and disadvantages this customization may present.
The Benefits of Using BMX Cranks on a Mountain Bike
Using BMX cranks on a mountain bike can provide several benefits. Firstly, BMX cranks are built to be incredibly strong and sturdy, making them ideal for the rough and tumble demands of mountain biking. This strength ensures that they can withstand the rigors of heavy downhill riding and high-speed impacts without breaking or buckling.
Secondly, the shorter length of BMX cranks can offer improved ground clearance and reduced pedal strikes, which can be particularly useful when maneuvering through technical sections of a trail or descending steep hills. Additionally, BMX cranks often have a smaller Q-factor, which is the distance between the pedals. This narrow profile can improve pedaling efficiency and make it easier to maintain a comfortable riding position on the bike.
In summary, using BMX cranks on a mountain bike can provide added durability, improved clearance and efficiency, and a more comfortable ride. However, it’s important to consider the specific needs of your riding style and terrain before making any changes to your bike’s crankset.
Read Also: How to Efficiently Change Brake Pads on Your Mountain Bike for Optimal Performance
The Mechanics Behind Adapting BMX Cranks to a Mountain Bike
Adapting BMX cranks to a mountain bike is technically possible, but it involves some mechanical work. The main issue with using BMX cranks on a mountain bike is that the chainring bolt circle diameter (BCD) is typically different from what is used in a mountain bike. BMX cranks are designed to fit smaller chainring sizes than those found on most mountain bikes.
To use BMX cranks on a mountain bike, you will need a special adapter that converts the BCD to match the larger chainrings found on a mountain bike. This adapter is usually a spider that bolts onto the BMX crank and allows for larger chainrings to be mounted. However, it is important to note that using a smaller chainring with BMX cranks on a mountain bike may result in less ground clearance and a higher risk of pedal strikes, which can be dangerous when riding off-road.
The Different Types of BMX Cranks Available and Which Ones are Compatible
BMX cranks are typically shorter than mountain bike (MTB) cranks, making them well-suited for the high torque needs of BMX riding. However, this also means compatibility can be an issue when attempting to install BMX cranks on a mountain bike. There are two main types of BMX cranks – 3-piece and 2-piece.
3-piece BMX cranks have three separate pieces – two arms that attach to the bottom bracket spindle and a spindle bolt. The two arms are connected by a splined spindle, allowing for a more secure connection and increased stiffness. 2-piece BMX cranks have two arms that are permanently connected to a spindle, and the entire assembly is installed directly into the bottom bracket without the need for a separate spindle bolt.
When looking for compatibility with a mountain bike, it is important to consider the bottom bracket type and size. BMX cranks typically have a 19mm spindle diameter, which may not fit in a mountain bike’s bottom bracket. It is also important to ensure that the chainring is compatible with the BMX crankset, as BMX chainrings have a smaller bolt circle diameter than most MTB chainrings. Overall, with proper research and careful consideration of compatibility, it is possible to install BMX cranks on a mountain bike.
You may also like: Best Kevlar Mountain Bike Tires for a Durable and Safe Ride.
Tips for Successfully Installing BMX Cranks on Your Mountain Bike
Installing BMX cranks on a mountain bike can give you the best of both worlds – the durability and strength of BMX cranks combined with the versatility and suspension capabilities of a mountain bike. However, successfully installing BMX cranks on a mountain bike requires careful consideration and attention to detail.
Firstly, ensure that the BMX cranks you purchase are compatible with your mountain bike frame and bottom bracket. Double-check the length of the cranks against your inseam length to ensure that they are the right size. Use a torque wrench to tighten the crank bolts to the recommended torque settings, as over-tightening can damage the threads on the bottom bracket. Finally, test the new cranks for any unusual noises or movements before taking your bike out on the trails. With these tips in mind, you can successfully install BMX cranks on your mountain bike and enjoy the benefits of enhanced durability and strength.
The Potential Risks and Drawbacks of Using BMX Cranks on a Mountain Bike
While the idea of using BMX cranks on a mountain bike might seem appealing, it’s important to note that there are some potential risks and drawbacks to consider before making the switch.
One of the most significant concerns is durability. BMX cranks are designed for the demanding environment of BMX racing, where jumps, bumps, and falls are par for the course. As a result, they tend to be thicker and heavier than their mountain bike counterparts. While this added material can provide additional strength, it can also make the bike less responsive and more difficult to handle. Additionally, using BMX cranks on a mountain bike could result in increased wear and tear on the crankset. This wear and tear could reduce the lifespan of the crank, leading to costly repairs or replacements down the road.
The Impact of Using BMX Cranks on Mountain Bike Performance
The impact of using BMX cranks on a mountain bike’s performance can vary depending on the rider and the type of riding they are doing. In general, BMX cranks tend to have a shorter length than mountain bike cranks, which can result in a quicker and more responsive pedal stroke. This can be advantageous for technical riding or racing, where quick bursts of power are needed.
However, using BMX cranks on a mountain bike can also result in a lower gear ratio, which may not be ideal for climbing steep hills or maintaining a steady pace on flat terrain. Additionally, BMX cranks may not be as durable as mountain bike cranks, especially in rough terrain. Therefore, it is important for riders to consider their individual riding style and needs before making any changes to their bike’s components.
Related Post: Best Mountain Bike Trail Gloves for a Comfortable Ride
Alternative Solutions for Improving Your Mountain Bike’s Power and Speed Without Using BMX Cranks.
Alternative Solutions for Improving Your Mountain Bike’s Power and Speed Without Using BMX Cranks
While BMX cranks may seem like a tempting solution for turning your mountain bike into a speed machine, it’s important to seek alternative solutions before making any drastic changes. Here are some options for improving your bike’s power and speed without resorting to BMX cranks.
1. Upgrade Your Bike’s Tires – The right tires can make a world of difference in terms of speed and power output. Consider investing in a pair of tires with low rolling resistance and a knobby tread for maximum grip.
2. Optimize Your Bike’s Gearing – Ensure your bike’s gearing is optimized for your riding style and terrain. Look into the possibility of adding a bigger chainring to increase top speed, or a smaller chainring to improve climbing abilities. Additionally, consider swapping out your cassette for a wide-range model to better suit your needs.
Final Verdict
Based on the research conducted, it is safe to say that it is possible to put BMX cranks on a mountain bike. However, it is important to keep in mind that doing so may have certain implications. For instance, using BMX cranks may make the mountain bike heavier and less efficient.
Furthermore, it is crucial to ensure that the crankset and bottom bracket are compatible and properly installed to avoid any potential safety hazards. In conclusion, while putting BMX cranks on a mountain bike is feasible, it is recommended to seek professional advice and assistance to ensure a smooth and safe operation of the bike.